The Department of Labor finalized its independent contractor rule, replacing the Biden-era standard and restoring a more employer-friendly, two-core-factor “economic reality” test modeled on the 2021 rule.
Why it matters: The final rule gives employers greater clarity and predictability on worker classification, potentially allowing them to offer benefits without jeopardizing a worker’s independent contractor status.
The details of the final rule:
Control over the work and opportunity for profit or loss remain the two “core” factors. Skill, permanence, and integration into the company’s production process carry less weight.
The rule also clarifies that the company’s and worker’s “actual practice” is more relevant than what may be contractually or theoretically possible.
The same test now applies under the FMLA and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act, not just the FLSA.
Benefits carve-out: The preamble to the final rule clarifies that providing benefits alone does not affect a worker’s classification as an employee or independent contractor.
This reverses the Biden-era rule, which treated healthcare and similar benefits as evidence of full employee status.
The change aligns with a growing trend at the state level, allowing employers to provide benefits to workers without impacting their contractor status.
CHRO Association cited by DOL: The final rule cites the Association’s submitted comments multiple times, specifically on the benefits carve-out, which speaks to our engagement in shaping the rule and discussion of this issue over the last 10 years.
Considerations for CHROs:
Audit contractor practices, not just contracts. Document how the work is performed when considering classification status.
Consider portable benefit programs for contractors. Check state law first since several states apply stricter classification tests that this rule does not displace.
Build practices that hold up under any test. Federal standards continue to shift between administrations, while courts and states may apply different classification tests.
